A systematic multi-instrument futures trading strategy validated across 5 years, 4 distinct market regimes, and 5 asset classes — surviving COVID, bear markets, and rate cycles.
BFR (Break, Fill, Return) is an institutional-grade mean-reversion strategy built on Smart Money Concepts. It identifies high-probability trade setups by detecting liquidity sweeps at Fair Value Gaps, confirmed by volume and session timing.
Each instrument was tested across 6 configurations including three Risk-Reward ratios (1:2, 1:3, 1:4) and three daily trade limit settings. Parameters were validated out-of-sample on 2020–2024 data.
| Config | RR | Daily Limit | Trades | Win Rate | Net R | R/Month | Max DD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A BEST | 1:2 | None | 1,506 | +2,329R | +38.8R | -9.0R | |
| B | 1:3 | None | 1,179 | +2,302R | +38.4R | -11.0R | |
| C | 1:4 | None | 1,019 | +2,134R | +35.6R | -14.4R | |
| D | 1:2 | 3/day | 572 | +528R | +8.8R | -9.0R | |
| E | 1:3 | 3/day | 525 | +492R | +8.2R | -11.0R | |
| F | 1:3 | 5/day | 639 | +784R | +13.1R | -11.0R |
| Config | RR | Limit | Trades | T/mo | WR% | Net R | R/mo | Max DD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A BEST | 1:2 | None | 1,042 | 17.4 | 81.0% | +1,426R | +23.8R | -11.0R |
| B | 1:3 | None | 817 | 13.6 | 72.3% | +1,167R | +19.4R | -18.3R |
| C | 1:4 | None | 737 | 12.3 | 67.4% | +1,091R | +18.2R | -17.3R |
| D | 1:2 | 3/day | 449 | 7.5 | 57.5% | +300R | +5.0R | -11.0R |
| E | 1:3 | 3/day | 420 | 7.0 | 47.9% | +276R | +4.6R | -20.4R |
| F | 1:3 | 5/day | 500 | 8.3 | 55.8% | +459R | +7.6R | -18.3R |
ADX filter paused trading on 313 of 1,556 days (20%), skipping 146 trades that would have been losers. Reduces drawdown significantly.
| Config | RR | Limit | Trades | T/mo | WR% | Net R | R/mo | Max DD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1:2 | None | 1,092 | 18.2 | 80.8% | +1,051R | +17.5R | -14.8R |
| B | 1:3 | None | 1,044 | 17.4 | 79.1% | +1,165R | +19.4R | -17.6R |
| C BEST | 1:4 | None | 1,034 | 17.2 | 78.6% | +1,174R | +19.6R | -15.6R |
| D | 1:2 | 3/day | 439 | 7.3 | 54.9% | +109R | +1.8R | -19.6R |
| E | 1:3 | 3/day | 427 | 7.1 | 51.8% | +90R | +1.5R | -23.4R |
| F | 1:3 | 5/day | 521 | 8.7 | 59.7% | +216R | +3.6R | -19.6R |
GC is the portfolio's hedge — best year was 2022 (+548R, 88.9% WR) when equities collapsed. RR=4 uniquely better due to gold's sweeping momentum moves.
| Config | RR | Limit | Trades | T/mo | WR% | Net R | R/mo | Max DD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1:2 | None | 601 | 10.0 | 86.7% | +901R | +15.0R | -11.8R |
| B BEST | 1:3 | None | 564 | 9.4 | 84.9% | +1,160R | +19.3R | -9.8R |
| C | 1:4 | None | 559 | 9.3 | 84.4% | +1,116R | +18.6R | -8.9R |
| D | 1:2 | 3/day | 186 | 3.1 | 58.6% | +126R | +2.1R | -11.8R |
| E | 1:3 | 3/day | 184 | 3.1 | 55.4% | +158R | +2.6R | -9.8R |
| F | 1:3 | 5/day | 226 | 3.8 | 63.3% | +255R | +4.2R | -9.8R |
| Config | RR | Limit | Trades | T/mo | WR% | Net R | R/mo | Max DD |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1:2 | None | 940 | 15.7 | 84.3% | +1,306R | +21.8R | -12.3R |
| B BEST | 1:3 | None | 771 | 12.8 | 79.0% | +1,315R | +21.9R | -13.3R |
| C | 1:4 | None | 702 | 11.7 | 75.6% | +1,129R | +18.8R | -20.3R |
| D | 1:2 | 3/day | 356 | 5.9 | 59.0% | +236R | +3.9R | -12.3R |
| E | 1:3 | 3/day | 338 | 5.6 | 52.1% | +240R | +4.0R | -14.2R |
| F | 1:3 | 5/day | 410 | 6.8 | 60.5% | +412R | +6.9R | -13.4R |
6B was positive when NQ collapsed in Q1 2025 (Jan 70% WR, Feb 75% WR). Genuine diversification benefit vs equity futures.
The strategy was tested across four distinct market environments. Only 2 instrument-years showed negative returns (GC and 6E in 2023), both recovered fully in 2024.
| Year & Regime | ES | NQ | GC | 6E | 6B | Portfolio Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
2020
COVID Crash
|
+666R · 91.2% ~302 trades · 25.2/mo |
+284R · 84.4% ~208 trades · 17.3/mo |
+187R · 76.7% ~207 trades · 17.3/mo |
+316R · 90.0% ~113 trades · 9.4/mo |
+401R · 92.6% ~154 trades · 12.8/mo |
+1,854R ~984 trades · 82/mo |
|
2021
Bull Market
|
+537R · 88.2% ~302 trades · 25.2/mo |
+279R · 84.5% ~208 trades · 17.3/mo |
+63R · 73.7% ~207 trades · 17.3/mo |
+619R · 89.3% ~113 trades · 9.4/mo |
+397R · 79.0% ~154 trades · 12.8/mo |
+1,895R ~984 trades · 82/mo |
|
2022
Bear Market
|
+408R · 82.0% ~302 trades · 25.2/mo |
+294R · 80.3% ~208 trades · 17.3/mo |
+548R · 88.9% ~207 trades · 17.3/mo |
+25R · 79.3% ~113 trades · 9.4/mo |
+87R · 66.2% ~154 trades · 12.8/mo |
+1,362R ~984 trades · 82/mo |
|
2023
Recovery/Chop
|
+341R · 79.2% ~302 trades · 25.2/mo |
+165R · 70.4% ~208 trades · 17.3/mo |
-6R · 41.2% ~207 trades · 17.3/mo |
-8R · 20.8% ~113 trades · 9.4/mo |
+303R · 79.8% ~154 trades · 12.8/mo |
+795R ~984 trades · 82/mo |
|
2024
Election Year
|
+377R · 85.6% ~298 trades · 24.8/mo |
+405R · 84.1% ~210 trades · 17.5/mo |
+382R · 79.2% ~206 trades · 17.2/mo |
+207R · 83.0% ~112 trades · 9.3/mo |
+128R · 63.6% ~155 trades · 12.9/mo |
+1,499R ~981 trades · 81.8/mo |
| 5-YEAR TOTAL |
+2,329R 1,506 trades 25.1/mo |
+1,426R 1,042 trades 17.4/mo |
+1,174R 1,034 trades 17.2/mo |
+1,160R 564 trades 9.4/mo |
+1,315R 771 trades 12.8/mo |
+7,404R 4,917 trades total 82.9/mo combined |
Optimal config selected per instrument based on highest Net R with acceptable drawdown profile.
Six major findings emerged from the 5-year, 66-backtest validation process. Each insight is backed by direct comparison across instruments and configurations.
Across all 5 instruments and 5 years, lower RR ratios generate more trades and higher total net R. But the optimal ratio varies by instrument volatility profile.
Based on 5-year validation results, each instrument receives a deployment classification. Tier 1 instruments are ready for live trading. All others require additional validation steps.
Validated position sizing and risk rules for live deployment.
Complete all items before placing first live trade.